DYNAMIC PROVIDER COMPARISON

PostScan Mail vs Anytime Mailbox

A side-by-side comparison generated from the same MailboxScout provider data used across this comparison engine, including a real-cost snapshot for common usage profiles.

VS
+
At a glance

Side-by-side comparison

The same criteria are used for every provider. “Varies” is shown where a network does not publish one universal fee or allowance.

CriteriaPostScan MailAnytime Mailbox
MailboxScout score8.9/108.6/10
Starting price$10/moFrom about $9.99/mo
Address network1,000+ addresses2,000+ locations
Address typeLarge network of street-address mailbox locationsMarketplace of local mailbox operators; exact address type and services vary
Incoming mail30 items/moVaries by local operator
Open & Scan$2/open & scan up to 10 pages on monthly StarterVaries by local operator
Forwarding$2 first item + $0.50 each additional + shippingVaries by local operator
Recipients1 on monthly StarterVaries by local operator
PackagesYes — package handling and pickup rules may varyLocation dependent
International forwardingForwarding available; destination and shipping costs varyLocation dependent
StorageStorage allowances/fees depend on item and plan rulesLocation/operator dependent
Check depositService availability variesSelected locations
App / accessWeb + mobile accessWeb + mobile access
Business useStrong — personal through business/enterprise tiersGood when the right local operator and city are available
Registered agentNot a universal core featureNot a universal network feature
USPS Form 1583Required for CMRA mailbox activationRequired where the mailbox operates as a U.S. CMRA
Where each provider stands out

Different strengths, not one universal winner

These category winners use MailboxScout’s editorial scoring for the underlying criteria. The factual row beneath each winner shows the provider data behind that distinction.

Entry-price valuePostScan Mail

$10/mo

Address choiceAnytime Mailbox

2,000+ locations

Scanning valuePostScan Mail

$2/open & scan up to 10 pages on monthly Starter

Forwarding economicsPostScan Mail

$2 first item + $0.50 each additional + shipping

Business fitPostScan Mail

Strong — personal through business/enterprise tiers

Pricing predictabilityPostScan Mail

Monthly and annual options; annual plans can include richer allowances.

Real-cost snapshot

Same usage, different bill

These estimates use the same simplified assumptions as the MailboxScout Real Cost model. Postage is included as the user-entered scenario budget. Anytime Mailbox is not standardized because local operator fees vary.

Open full calculator

Scenario: 10 mail items · 3 Open & Scan requests · 18 scanned pages · 1 forwarding shipment(s) · $8.00 postage budget.

Scenario: 25 mail items · 8 Open & Scan requests · 45 scanned pages · 2 forwarding shipment(s) · $15.00 postage budget.

Scenario: 55 mail items · 20 Open & Scan requests · 120 scanned pages · 4 forwarding shipment(s) · $28.00 postage budget.

Bottom line

Who each provider fits best

PostScan Mail

Best fit: Balanced features and locations

Main limitation: Entry-plan Open & Scan and forwarding handling can add meaningful usage charges.

Monthly and annual options; annual plans can include richer allowances.

Anytime Mailbox

Best fit: Local address choice

Main limitation: The exact location must be checked carefully because inclusions and fees vary materially by operator.

The starting figure is not universal; each local operator can set its own plan and fees.

Important: Provider prices, location availability and operating rules can change. Marketplace networks can also vary by local operator. Verify the exact address and current provider terms before purchasing. Real-cost figures are estimates, not quotes.